Thursday's Hangover : FED - Quid ECB - Bomb shell ?

Published: August 2, 2012 - 00:38
This article received :  12 Comments
draghi-bernanke.jpg

Well we had quite a colorful US morning session yesterday. In the first half hour after the opening bell, an algo trading program went bananas affecting some 148 stocks amongst which some very big names. For more info on this we refer to

Now over to the more "serious" stuff and the market reaction to the FOMC decision. Bearish language, the expected low rate commitment until at least end of 2014 and setting hopes on Congress to sort out the budgetary mess. Ready to act but no new monetary initiatives. Has the toolbox run dry ? Is one afraid of negative rate territory ? Or is one trying to pull the psychological trick that when nothing new is required, we are basically OK and thus up we go ? Difficult to read this one but the US Treasury in the mean time announced something new (or fairly new) : From next year onwards, the US Treasury will next to the usual T-Bills and bonds also issue floating rate Treasuries (3 and 6 month ibor reset). And it could involve a substantial program up to 70-100 bio USD. Is this required to convince foreign investors to buy US debt with a safe duration feature ? Yep, and the Chinese are back in the game.

Now over to Europe and this afternoon's big one. Well big one because Mario wanted it this way in view of his speech last Friday. And in combination with the Hollande/Merkel announcement, it sounded as if it was a pretty done deal. Now we had some radio silence and we know Draghi and Weidemann are in marathon session to come out with something. From what we thought was the most easy part - granting the banking license to ESM - it seems this is no longer evident. And when it comes to printing à la FED/BoE/BoJ, the Germans are not going to give a free green light. So has Mario cornered himself ?

Lets have a look at what has happened over past 10 months. Also back then, we had a sovereign debt crisis up-flaring and a full blown bank liquidity crisis. So Mario creatively tried to solve both issues by LTRO 1 and 2 : a lender of the last resort - in full compliance with its legal capabilities - granting over 1,000 bio of loans against collateral by which it secured bank refinancing for the next 3 years. And with the abundant liquidity, it hoped/urged banks to use the excess money to shore up sovereign debt, by this depressing Spanish and Italian yields. It succeeded for a brief moment in time because when Spring went into Summer and the Spanish Summer went into a Russian Winter, it's back to square 1. For an overview of the main balance sheet operations :

http://www.ecb.int/mopo/implement/omo/html/index.en.html

http://www.ecb.int/mopo/liq/html/index.en.html#portfolios

So if outright bond buying is not on the menu when Weidemann gets his way, does it mean Mario comes home empty handed ? Not necessarily ; check the last link and the graph underneath. It concerns the SMP or Securities Markets Programme :

350px-ECB_SMP_Bond_Purchases.png

Now this program came to life after the first EMU crisis outburst following the Greek debt saga. And in those days - because of unusual uncertain market circumstances - the ECB started the buying program especially on Greek bonds (approx 60 bio EUR) ; on the side, it did on a much smaller scale the same for covered bonds ; In autumn 2011, it repeated the exercise mainly focusing on Spain and Italy. Mind you, this was still under Trichet, not Draghi, with the programme stopping at 212 bio EUR cumulative. Then came Draghi, LTRO 1 and 2 and the programme has not been reactivated ever since (nov 2011). So is this what Draghi was hinting at last week, saying there were plenty of options, a kind of joker up the sleeve and threat to Weidemann : "if you don't play along, I invoke the special Securities Markets Programme". Could well be the case. Any way, Mario has now provided markets with a target and they might come out and test it : Send those yields back to 6%/7% plus territory. But then of course Mario will have every right to invoke this pogramme because of uncertain and stressful market circumstances....

So we've reached critical position of the chess middle game. Position is very much closed with opponents defending their pieces and trying to exert pressure on each other's weak squares. You can end the game by shaking hands and call it a draw. Or you can pull a magician's trick by dropping an unexpected bomb shell on your opponent's firewall. Is Draghi like Mischa Tal, a magician or attacking maniac (or both) ? We will very soon find out.

12 Comments

  1. Nacht Und Nebel 

    On 2 Aug, 2012

    Does Mario really have to do anything?Didn't the Germans already lost the game a long time ago.
    What are the options for Germany.
    1.To walk away and lose big time on defaulting debt
    2.To stay in and pay the price for the walloonization of Europe

    How can you win if:
    -your banks have invested about 500 billion in southern debt
    -Germany’s EFSF guarantees are about 211 billion
    -Germany's ESM guarantees are about 280 billion and that fund is already as good as empty
    -Germany has an TARGET2 exposure of about 700 billion and is expanding about 100 billion a year
    -If Germany walks away they crash the world economy and 40 percent of their GDP is export to Asia Eastern Europe US and Brazil

    Germany doesn't play to win but plays to lose rhe least as possible.
    Don't you hear Mario singing

    http://youtu.be/xcHxkc3q68s

    You just can't win a losing game:)

    1. Nacht Und Nebel 

      On 2 Aug, 2012

      Germany's battle of the Bulge revisited :)

      http://youtu.be/4t7zOs5oFJ8
    1. christof Govaerts 

      On 2 Aug, 2012

      @NuN
      Yep, to the point remarks, except that Frankfurt's Buba doesn't seem to agree on this. Or are they just putting on a brave show ?
  2. Nacht Und Nebel 

    On 2 Aug, 2012

    Christof,

    Did Mario cornered himself or the Buba?He has the perfect excuse now.I must act now or we all face the consequences.

    1. christof Govaerts 

      On 2 Aug, 2012

      @NuN
      Yep, and the question then is : on who will he be dropping a bomb shell : Mr Market, Germany, both ?
    1. christof Govaerts 

      On 2 Aug, 2012

      @NuN
      Yep, and even our cold hearted Fins are making a U-Turn ; from Bloomberg

      "We have been very critical on secondary market operations by rescue funds and central banks. We don't believe that's the right way to use money. Still, the situation on sovereign bond markets is not normal and a sort of solution is required here". Finnish PM Katainen elaborating on his "extraordinary" meeting with Italian PM Monti
      1. Nacht Und Nebel 

        On 2 Aug, 2012

        Your right about Mario.He knows how to play the game.Poor germans Poor Mr Market.Poor us:(
  3. Philippe 

    On 2 Aug, 2012

    Judging by his press conference, Mario had a plan : mesmerizing anyone and everyone to to some form of blind euphoria to kick the can a bit further down the road. So, if I understand well, it's not a plan to do something, not even a plan to have a plan, but a plan to make people believe there is a plan to have a plan that will bring a solution to the absence of plan.

    Like I said yesterday, this smells sulphur dioxyde.
    1. Nacht Und Nebel 

      On 2 Aug, 2012

      Philippe,

      For now the fat lady isn't doing the full monti yet.hell she doesn't even sing.Still Mario still has the upper hand even if the plan was to have no plan at all.Market turmoil will favor Mario.The question is not if the ESM will have a banking lincence in the near future but how limited the leverage will be.
      But you are right.With or without a banking lincence central banks are expert can kickers
      1. christof Govaerts 

        On 2 Aug, 2012

        @Philippe
        Indeed, in a war of attrition against the Buba and went the shit hits the fan, Mario can and probably will invoke SMP
      1. Nacht Und Nebel 

        On 2 Aug, 2012

        http://youtu.be/q7NyE8o5fxk
        1. Nacht Und Nebel 

          On 2 Aug, 2012

          hot potato:)

          http://youtu.be/NBWQCHb95rg

Post a comment

max. length of 1500 characters